OLD CHATHAM QUAKERS
  • Home
  • What's Going On?
    • Calendar
    • Upcoming Events
  • Donate
  • More About Us
    • Location
    • Quaker Links
    • Renting the Meeting House
  • Meeting Life
    • Meeting Business
    • Meeting Directory
    • Miscellaneous Documents
    • Document Archive
    • Worship Sharing
    • The Role of Ministry and Counsel
    • Friends Burial Ground at Rayville
    • Photo Archive
  • Covid Policy
  • OCMM Visibility Strategy Survey
  • Blog
  • Sanctuary Documents
  • OPJ Documents
  • Solitary Housing Unit

John Silber and Opportunity for All

3/11/2022

2 Comments

 
Probably several OCMM members remember John Silber. After all, Massachusetts is New York’s neighbor, and Silber was President or Chancellor of Boston University from 1971 to 2003. He was also the Democratic nominee for Governor of Massachusetts in the 1990 election, which he lost to Republican William Weld. Although Silber taught at Yale while he worked on his Ph.D., his first full-time faculty position was as a professor of philosophy at the University of Texas in Austin.

When I arrived at the University of Texas in 1964, I enrolled in Plan II, an honors degree plan in Liberal Arts. One of Plan II’s required courses was an introductory philosophy course taught by John Silber. As I sat in his class the first day, I immediately noticed that his right arm was half as long as normal, ending in a stump with rudimentary fingers. I don’t remember for sure, but Silber probably gave us our first assignment on that first day. We were to write a short paper in which we discussed objectivity as applied in the sciences and the liberal arts.

I do remember very well the class in which that assignment was returned to us. Silber shuffled through the papers, seemingly wanting to toss them aside (perhaps into the trash can), a look of impatient disgust upon his face. He read excerpts from what appeared to be a random selection of student work. Apparently, most of us (myself included) had argued that science approached the world objectively while humanists could only give their subjective impressions of reality. That provoked John Silber, who proceeded to demolish our naiveté with irrefutable proofs that all knowledge was subjective, whether scientific or not.

John Silber was smart, and I couldn’t help respecting his intellect and his passionate personality. In fact, my interest in philosophy has its roots in Silber’s philosophy course. However, from my first encounter with him, I guessed that Silber carried around a load of anger related to his defective arm. Tom Wolfe—the famous journalist—seems to confirm my suspicions when he writes that  

(Other kids) …called him (Silber) “One-Arm Pete.” His only recourse, he
finally concluded, was to punch the little trolls out, small and handicapped   
though he was. He punched with his left fist and used his truncated
right arm like a cattle prod. The bone was just under the skin of his
proto-fingers, and when he jammed it into his little combatants’
stomachs or kidneys—Aha! Thrust PRODDDD!—they would go oof or
arrrgggh!...the action would come to a halt, and little John Silber
could take a break. If he didn’t have a quick temper and a pugnacious
side before all that, he sure did afterward. (Seeking the North Star, p. XII)    

 
In fact, Silber probably lost the 1990 gubernatorial election because of a display of temper during an interview, seen HERE in a YouTube video.  

 Regardless of his failure as a politician, Silber led a successful life full of achievement. He was a noted scholar of Immanuel Kant’s philosophy and took Boston College from a mediocre “streetcar school” to the status of a world-class university dedicated first and foremost to teaching students. Tom Wolfe calls Silber a Stoic because he embodied in his life the philosophy and values he preached.

One of those values was providing educational opportunities to the poor and disadvantaged. Silber wanted to create an elite class of educated people whose status was based on ability as opposed to wealth or family connections. Their success would be the result of a capacity to reason through problems, and that
reasoning ability would be acquired through quality primary, secondary, and university schooling.   

While I agree with Silber’s idea of opportunity for all, neither Silber nor I believe that the lower classes in American society can attain equality with the elite. (Otherwise, there wouldn’t BE an elite!) A combination of genes, environment, bad luck, and personal choice conspire to keep people “down.” However, we can  potentially have a society and culture where everyone is respected whether they cashier in Walmart or design rocket engines.

That respect may best come, not so much through reason and education, as through a belief like the Quaker “that of God in everyone.” If we acknowledge that we are not self-created, that our talents and gifts come from God, we are more likely to see a “holy equality” in all human beings. All of us share in each other’s achievements because—ultimately—we are all the “same” in God. Thus, religion or spirituality—not education—is the solution to the problem of inequality. In the Kingdom of God proclaimed by Jesus, nobody is above anybody else.  

(The sources for this article are my memory and Seeking the North Star: Selected Speeches by John R. Silber.)
 
~ Richard Russell  
2 Comments
Donald Newman Lathrop
3/18/2022 07:56:30 pm

HI Richard,

This is a fascinating paragraph.

"That respect may best come, not so much through reason and education, as through a belief like the Quaker “that of God in everyone.” If we acknowledge that we are not self-created, that our talents and gifts come from God, we are more likely to see a “holy equality” in all human beings. All of us share in each other’s achievements because—ultimately—we are all the “same” in God. Thus, religion or spirituality—not education—is the solution to the problem of inequality. In the Kingdom of God proclaimed by Jesus, nobody is above anybody else."

I agree that all individuals are equally worthy of opportunity and dignity. On the other hand, I'm sure you can observe from your cash register that the lives of your customers
don't appear to demonstrate equal opportunities being lived out.

To see them as all equivalent on a spiritual level does not seem to afford them equal qualities of lives being lived. Peace,
Don

Reply
Richard Russell
3/19/2022 05:49:01 pm

Hi, Don.

I agree that spiritual and economic/social status are two different "equalities." Silber and I would want to make the poor and disadvantaged LESS unequal in a socio-economic sense and equal in the respect in which they are held as human beings. Of course, people tie respect and socio-economic status together. If you're poorer, you're not as well thought of.

For enlightened religious people (e.g., Quakers, liberal Protestants and Catholics), it should be easier to acknowledge the innate worth of the poor. In fact, Jesus seemed to PREFER the poor! Talk about an inversion of values!

I agree with you that "opportunity" is not enough for a better "lived-out" equality. Radical income re-distribution is necessary, I think, as well as a major shift in our American culture from materialism to the simpler living advocated by most Friends. Sadly, I see neither income redress nor cultural shift coming soon to the U.S.. (But let's not give up hope.)

As always, grateful for your well-thought-out comments.

Richard

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    ​This blog was set up to post content of interest to Old Chatham Quaker members and attenders. Posts related to one's own personal spiritual journey, reports based on interviews with others, and reflections on Quaker-related topics are welcome. Posts by individuals are personal expressions and do not necessarily reflect those of the Meeting as a whole.
    Guidelines for posting on website blog:
    Submit to member of Communications committee; committee has editorial oversight over all content posted on the Meeting website.

    Be respectful of the nature of vocal ministry given in Meeting for Worship or other settings and any private conversations about spiritual matters.

    Cite source of any image or other external content submitted.

    Archives

    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • What's Going On?
    • Calendar
    • Upcoming Events
  • Donate
  • More About Us
    • Location
    • Quaker Links
    • Renting the Meeting House
  • Meeting Life
    • Meeting Business
    • Meeting Directory
    • Miscellaneous Documents
    • Document Archive
    • Worship Sharing
    • The Role of Ministry and Counsel
    • Friends Burial Ground at Rayville
    • Photo Archive
  • Covid Policy
  • OCMM Visibility Strategy Survey
  • Blog
  • Sanctuary Documents
  • OPJ Documents
  • Solitary Housing Unit